Scenic view of a calm lake reflecting a hillside covered with trees displaying fall colors, under a clear blue sky.

Property Management of Hayward

Management You Can Trust. Stays You’ll Love.

Book your stay
A cozy outdoor scene in front of a rustic stone and wood lodge during sunset, featuring a campfire surrounded by green Adirondack chairs with red and black checkered blankets.

Welcome to Hayward Rentals —Your trusted partner for rental property management and quality guest stays in Northern Wisconsin.

We serve both property owners who want dependable, full-service management — and guests looking for clean, comfortable and professionally maintained rentals.

For owners, we handle everything: tenant and guest screening, rental marketing, bookings, maintenance coordination, inspections, rent collection, financial reporting and 24/7 support. We minimize vacancies, protect your investment and ensure your property performs at its best.

For guests, we provide a smooth, stress-free experience with easy online booking, responsive communication, high cleaning standards, and well-cared-for homes in great locations.

Whether you're investing, renting or staying for a weekend — you’re in the right place.

Aerial view of a lakeside house with a backyard, surrounded by trees, with a dock and boat on the water.
A wooden picnic table with attached benches is outdoors on mossy ground near a large woodpile with firewood stacked under a shelter in a forested area.
View of a wooden dock with two Adirondack chairs overlooking a lake, with trees and hills in the background.
A cozy bedroom with wood-paneled walls and ceiling, featuring a bed with a rustic wooden headboard and an ornate, curved wooden frame. The room includes a window seat with pillows, framed botanical art on the walls, a ceiling fan, and various lamps, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Our Top Properties

Browse all properties

Want your property featured here? Reach out and let’s get started.

Your Hayward Escape Starts Here

  • A rustic bedroom with wooden walls, a bed with colorful striped bedding and pillows, two nightstands with lamps, a window with red curtains, two chairs with red and black cushions, a small striped rug, and framed artwork on the walls.

    Cozy rooms

  • View from a kayak on a calm lake during sunset, with water droplets on the kayak and a distant shoreline with hills.

    Kayaking

  • A Canada goose stretching its wings in water.

    Wildlife

  • A winding road surrounded by trees with vibrant autumn yellow and green leaves, fallen leaves scattered on the road.

    Forests

  • Aerial view of a lake with small tree-covered islands and a surrounding forest under a partly cloudy sky.

    Lakes

  • Man smiling and holding up a fish he caught, outdoors near a body of water with a cloudy sky.

    Fishing

Discover Hayward, WI

Located in the heart of Wisconsin’s Northwoods, Hayward is a place where pristine lakes, towering pines, and abundant wildlife create a truly unforgettable setting.

Visitors come for the world-class fishing, boating, hiking, and hundreds of miles of ATV and snowmobile trails — and stay for the peaceful mornings, loons calling across the water, deer grazing at dusk, and the occasional eagle soaring overhead.

With year-round festivals, local shops, and endless outdoor activities, Hayward offers something for every kind of traveler. Whether you’re seeking adventure, relaxation, or a chance to reconnect with nature, this is the perfect place to unwind and take in the beauty of the Northwoods.

A common loon swimming on a body of water. The bird has black and white patterned feathers, a black head with a red eye, and a sharp black beak.
Young deer resting among green bushes with its head turned to the side, showing large ears and dark eyes.
Learn more
A sea otter floating in water with its head above the surface, looking to the right.

About Us

We’re Dustin and Mikayla — local owners, rental hosts, and the team behind Property Management of Hayward.

With years of experience in real estate, property management, and hospitality, we’re dedicated to maintaining well-cared-for homes and providing reliable, responsive service.

We believe in clear communication, modern systems, and treating every property like our own. From owners who want trustworthy management to guests who want a clean, comfortable stay, we’re here to make things easy, welcoming, and worry-free.

Learn more
A smiling couple embraces in front of an old, red, weathered wooden wall, with the woman hugging the man from behind.
  • A close-up of fallen autumn leaves in a pond with reflections of trees on the water surface.

    Great service & communication!

    I've been using PMH for many years for my annual trip to the Birkie. The service and communication is great. What I really truly appreciate though is that Dustin treats me being an annually returning customer with a ton of respect. They always reach out after the race to support with rebooking, which is greatly appreciated as it takes one major part of trip planning off my plate. I appreciate a great alternative to AirBNB to be able to support local folks.

    Amanda Stone

  • A paved forest trail surrounded by trees with colorful fall foliage, showing green, yellow, and orange leaves.

    Highly recommended!

    We've been working with Dustin and the folks at PMH Vacation Rentals for over 15 years. They are professional, positive and always eager to help. Many of the rentals they provide are pet friendly which works well for us since we have two black labs. PMH ensures everything is ready when you arrive at your rental. Someone is always available to help if a problem does come up. My family and I have never been disappointed in the service and follow up provided by PMH. We will continue to use them now and in the future when planning our family vacations. I highly recommend PMH and personally feel they are the best rental agency in the greater Hayward area.

    Kurt Rasmussen

  • A wooden paddle in a boat on a calm lake with a distant tree-lined shoreline at sunset.

    Very responsive, friendly and professional.

    We have been renting vacation homes from PMH for many many years. We have stayed on 4 different lakes over the years and have already booked for next year! The properties are clean, very nice, well maintained and exactly as described. Many properties have additional games, kayaks and other entertainment features. The folks at PMH are very responsive, friendly and professional. I can’t say enough about this company! They have great choices on so many lakes and have the best pet friendly options in the Northwoods. A big shout out to Dustin and this great company for helping our family make special memories year after year!

    Lisa MacKay